You introduced two friends and now you're the one left out: What to do next
There’s nothing more exciting than introducing two friends, hoping that they’ll also bond and connect so that you become a group. You start a group chat, make plans, and suddenly you have the friend group you’ve always wanted. But what happens when the two of them bond, your group chat goes quiet yet you start seeing them out and you’re the only one that’s always consistently left out. You’re not upset they became friends because that’s why you introduced them in the first place. You’re upset that they stopped including you.
So what do you do? Do you say something or do you just slowly start withdrawing from the friendship because they should know what they’re doing?
First, let’s figure out what actually changed.
Do you know if they deliberately pushed you out? There’s a difference between two friends developing their own friendship and two friends consistently excluding the person who introduced them.
Situation A: They occasionally get coffee together but both still reach out, invite you to things, and make an effort to maintain their individual friendships with you. I wouldn’t do anything here.
Situation B: They regularly make plans without you, rarely initiate with you anymore, and you only see them when you’re the one organizing something. I’d pay closer attention to see if the friendship has become one sided.
Situation C: They continue to invite you to larger gatherings but have stopped including you in the smaller, more spontaneous plans you used to make together. I’d consider whether you’re still friends but no longer as close as you once were.
The question isn’t whether they’re allowed to spend time without you, of course they are. The question is whether they’re still making an effort to maintain a friendship with you.
Don’t immediately pull back to see if they’ll notice
I know how tempting this is, especially after you saw they went out to dinner again without you and you decide you’re done initiating. The problem with pulling back as a test is that it doesn’t always give you the information you think it does. They may actually then think you’re busy, want space, or stopped prioritizing the relationship.
Instead, try One intentional attempt to reconnect before deciding what to do next:
For a group plan: “Hey! I feel like we haven’t all gotten together in a while. Want to do dinner (whatever plan you used to do regularly) next week or the following?”
Or
For 1:1 plan: “I miss catching up with you! Are you free for (whatever plan you used to do together) next week or the following?”
You don’t need to keep initiating indefinitely but one clear invite does tell you more than weeks of silently waiting for someone to notice that you’ve disappeared.
When you find out they made plans without you
You open up Instagram stories and there you see them out again here are some options:
-If you want to be included next time, try expressing interest once (don’t keep reminding them after that): “That restaurant looked so good! I’d love to join you guys next time!”
-They keep doing it after the fact, don’t accuse them of stealing your friendship, it always goes wrong: “I’d love for us to make plans again, I feel like it’s been forever since the three of us/just us have hung out. Have you noticed that too?”
-You don’t want to bring it up but you also don’t want to keep chasing: Remain friendly but yes, you don’t have to keep trying to chase a friendship if they’re not choosing you too. Just don’t let it become a decision you’re making to get their attention.
If they call you jealous
You finally say something and now they’re replying with “are you seriously upset that we’re friends?” or “we’re allowed to hang out with you.” You then freeze or start defending yourself, which doesn’t seem to help. Here’s what to try:
“I’m so happy that you’ve gotten close! I’ve only just missed spending time together.” Then full stop. If they continue you can try: “I’m only saying that I miss hanging out.”
They say, “We should all get together” but never includes you.
Instead of continuing the vague exchange, try making a specific plan:
“I’d love that! Are you free Thursday or Friday?" Offer two options, so they’re more likely to pick one.
Your Homework:
Identify on what you actually miss. Is it the group dinners? Feeling included in plans? What was it? Be as specific as possible.
Make one clear way attempt to reconnect. Don’t hint or wait for them to read your mind.
Look for reciprocal effort. If they’re unavailable, do they offer another time? Do they initiate again? Do they seem interested in maintaining the connection?
Going through something? Head to Dear Dr. C and ask away! Prefer a private 1:1? Head to book a session above and members get 10% off with code: Member.
xo,
Dr. C