When the Group Chat Turns Toxic: Stay, Mute, or Leave?
At some point, many adult women find themselves thinking something they never expected to think again, Why does this feel like high school? Side conversations, awkward silences, being included just enough to stay on the thread but not enough to feel secure. Recently, Ashley Tisdale put words to this experience when she said a group dynamic felt like high school and she left. That moment resonated because it named something real but here’s what most advice gets wrong, what works for one very public moment doesn’t always work in real life, especially when you still see these people at school drop off, birthdays, neighborhood events, or mutual friends’ gatherings. So let’s talk about what actually helps.
The Double Bind No One Talks About
If you’re in a toxic or uncomfortable group dynamic, you’ve probably already discovered this:
Calling it out escalates things
Staying silent maintains the dynamic
So what are you supposed to do if you’ve already tried to repair once, calmly, directly, in good faith, and nothing changed? This is where most people get stuck.
First: Why Calling It Out Rarely Works
Naming a group dynamic out loud (“This feels immature,” “This is giving high school,” “I don’t like how this group operates”) might feel honest but in group settings, it usually does one of three things:
Triggers defensiveness
Creates side-taking and gossip
Shifts attention from the behavior to your reaction
In other words, it creates the very drama you were trying to escape. While clarity feels satisfying in the moment, it doesn’t equal calm, especially in group dynamics.
Why Silence Alone Doesn’t Work Either
On the other hand, staying completely silent while remaining emotionally invested quietly reinforces the status quo. You’re still available, still affected, and still absorbing the impact. Silence without an internal shift becomes self-abandonment. So what’s the alternative?
The Third Option: Regulated Disengagement
After you’ve tried to repair once, the goal is no longer to fix the dynamic. The goal is to change how much access it has to you, this is what I call regulated disengagement. It’s not confrontation, it’s not ghosting, and it’s not performative maturity. It’s staying calm, boring, and minimally reactive while quietly redirecting your energy elsewhere.
How to Decide: Stay, Mute, or Leave
If there’s no clear fallout
Mute the group chat.
Muting:
Protects your nervous system
Prevents impulsive reactions
Keeps you from becoming the topic
Allows you to observe without absorbing
This isn’t avoidance, it’s strategic emotional regulation.
If the tension is subtle or ambiguous
Stay in the chat but stop over-participating. No initiating, no fixing, and no emotional labor. You’re present without being invested.
If there has been a clear rupture and it’s past repair
Leaving may be appropriate but here’s the key:
Don’t announce it, label it, or explain it. Leaving quietly is about closing a door that’s already shut, not making a statement.
What to Say (and What Not to Say)
If someone says: “You seem distant.” Use calm, non-dramatic responses:
“Life has been so full lately.”
“Time has been so tight.”
“I’ve just been juggling a bit more than usual.”
These responses acknowledge without reopening the conversation.
In the group chat itself
Instead of engaging emotionally, respond neutrally:
“Appreciate the update.”
“Good to know, thanks.”
Short, polite, and closed-ended.
What Not to Do After a Failed Repair
Don’t keep explaining
Don’t seek validation from the group
Don’t hope maturity will suddenly be reciprocated
Don’t stay emotionally invested to prove you’re “handling it well”
Once behavior doesn’t change, the information is clear.
The Most Important Mindset Shift
You don’t need to name something as “high school” to outgrow it. In fact, saying that out loud often recreates the dynamic you’re trying to escape. Growth doesn’t look like confrontation, it looks like calm, boring boundaries and quiet redirection of energy.
Your Final Takeaway:
Once you’ve tried to repair:
You’re not responsible for fixing the group
You’re not obligated to stay emotionally available
And you don’t need to make a scene to protect your peace
You don’t escalate, you don’t disappear, you simply de-center the group. That’s not passive, that’s power.
Going through something? Head to The Lounge and ask away, I'll get back to you with tailored scripts and tips and you’ll stay anonymous. Prefer to chat 1:1, head to the Book a session tab above and members get a 10% discount with code: Member.
xo,
Dr. C